EclipseZone - EMF Refactoring Plugin ...

The Rich Engineering Heritage Behind Dependency Injection

Andrew McVeigh takes us on a tour of the rich heritage behind dependency injection, what it represents, and tells us why its here to stay.

Java, the OLPC, and community responsibility

The "One Laptop Per Child" project has a great device ready to ship, but there's no Java on there. Let's think about working together to put Java on OLPC!

Replies: 14 - Pages: 1
Threads: [ Previous | Next ]

Reply 1. At 4:28 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Eike Stepper wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Hi Lars,

This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.

Cheers
/Eike

Lars Schneider schrieb:
> Hi,
>
> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a first
> version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion but my email
> was not delivered.
> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first version
> he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update site here
> because it is not ready to be published yet.
>
> Lars Schneider
Reply 2. At 4:43 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Timothy Marc wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Dear Lars,

i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.

Thx
Timothy
"Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
> Hi Lars,
>
> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>
> Cheers
> /Eike
>
>
> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>> Hi,
>>
>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a first
>> version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion but my email
>> was not delivered.
>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first version he
>> or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update site here because
>> it is not ready to be published yet.
>>
>> Lars Schneider
Reply 3. At 6:58 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Lars Schneider wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted you
guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you the
update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is updated
because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they will reply
quickly.

lars

Timothy Marc wrote:
> Dear Lars,
>
> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>
> Thx
> Timothy
> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>> Hi Lars,
>>
>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>
>> Cheers
>> /Eike
>>
>>
>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a first
>>> version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion but my email
>>> was not delivered.
>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first version he
>>> or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update site here because
>>> it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>
>>> Lars Schneider
>
>
Reply 4. At 7:03 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Tom Schindl wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Hi Lars,

Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the sources
there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to look into
sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.

Tom

Lars Schneider schrieb:
> Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted you
> guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you the
> update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is updated
> because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they will reply
> quickly.
>
> lars
>
> Timothy Marc wrote:
>> Dear Lars,
>>
>> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>>
>> Thx
>> Timothy
>> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
>> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>>> Hi Lars,
>>>
>>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>>
>>> Cheers
>>> /Eike
>>>
>>>
>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>> Hi,
>>>>
>>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a first
>>>> version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion but my
>>>> email was not delivered.
>>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first version
>>>> he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update site here
>>>> because it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>>
>>>> Lars Schneider
>>
>>

--
B e s t S o l u t i o n . at
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Tom Schindl JFace-Committer
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Reply 5. At 7:09 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Lars Schneider wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
If IBM employees can not access the update sites (located at Uni Marburg
and TU Berlin) I'll have to. But then I have to ask the people from
Berlin if it is okay to attach their sources, too, because of the
dependencies mentioned above.

Tom Schindl wrote:
> Hi Lars,
>
> Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the sources
> there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to look into
> sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.
>
> Tom
>
> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>> Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted
>> you guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you
>> the update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is
>> updated because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they
>> will reply quickly.
>>
>> lars
>>
>> Timothy Marc wrote:
>>> Dear Lars,
>>>
>>> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>>>
>>> Thx
>>> Timothy
>>> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
>>> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>>>> Hi Lars,
>>>>
>>>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>>>
>>>> Cheers
>>>> /Eike
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>
>>>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a
>>>>> first version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion but
>>>>> my email was not delivered.
>>>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first
>>>>> version he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update
>>>>> site here because it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>>>
>>>>> Lars Schneider
>>>
>>>
>
>
Reply 6. At 7:18 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Tom Schindl wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Hi Lars,

The problem is not that can't access them the problem is that they are
*not allowed to look at the sources by their employee* (Ed isn't an
IBMer anymore so this might not be a problem for him anymore .

So if you want to have feedback you need to provide the sources through
bugzilla and under EPL!

Tom

Lars Schneider schrieb:
> If IBM employees can not access the update sites (located at Uni Marburg
> and TU Berlin) I'll have to. But then I have to ask the people from
> Berlin if it is okay to attach their sources, too, because of the
> dependencies mentioned above.
>
> Tom Schindl wrote:
>> Hi Lars,
>>
>> Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the sources
>> there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to look into
>> sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.
>>
>> Tom
>>
>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>> Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted
>>> you guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you
>>> the update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is
>>> updated because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they
>>> will reply quickly.
>>>
>>> lars
>>>
>>> Timothy Marc wrote:
>>>> Dear Lars,
>>>>
>>>> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>>>>
>>>> Thx
>>>> Timothy
>>>> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
>>>> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>>>>> Hi Lars,
>>>>>
>>>>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>>>>
>>>>> Cheers
>>>>> /Eike
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a
>>>>>> first version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion
>>>>>> but my email was not delivered.
>>>>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first
>>>>>> version he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update
>>>>>> site here because it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Lars Schneider
>>>>
>>>>
>>
>>

--
B e s t S o l u t i o n . at
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Tom Schindl JFace-Committer
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Reply 7. At 7:23 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Ed Merks wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Lars,

I suppose you emailed my IBM address and since I'm no longer at IBM,
that won't work so well. My gmail email address will work better when
using Ed.Merks in combination with it. We're certainly badly in need of
refactoring support so that would make a very interesting component to
develop at Eclipse. I think lots of people would be interested in this,
so opening a bugzilla in which to add attachments or links would allow
many people to review it and comment on it. I look forward to seeing
the details!

Lars Schneider wrote:
> If IBM employees can not access the update sites (located at Uni
> Marburg and TU Berlin) I'll have to. But then I have to ask the people
> from Berlin if it is okay to attach their sources, too, because of the
> dependencies mentioned above.
>
> Tom Schindl wrote:
>> Hi Lars,
>>
>> Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the
>> sources there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to
>> look into sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.
>>
>> Tom
>>
>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>> Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted
>>> you guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you
>>> the update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is
>>> updated because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they
>>> will reply quickly.
>>>
>>> lars
>>>
>>> Timothy Marc wrote:
>>>> Dear Lars,
>>>>
>>>> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>>>>
>>>> Thx
>>>> Timothy
>>>> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
>>>> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>>>>> Hi Lars,
>>>>>
>>>>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>>>>
>>>>> Cheers
>>>>> /Eike
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a
>>>>>> first version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion
>>>>>> but my email was not delivered.
>>>>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first
>>>>>> version he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update
>>>>>> site here because it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Lars Schneider
>>>>
>>>>
>>
>>
Reply 8. At 8:00 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Lars Schneider wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Ed,

yes, I wrote to merks @ ibm. I was going to open a bugzilla but wasn't
sure how to fill out the forms. Is there an example you can give?

Lars

Ed Merks wrote:
> Lars,
>
> I suppose you emailed my IBM address and since I'm no longer at IBM,
> that won't work so well. My gmail email address will work better when
> using Ed.Merks in combination with it. We're certainly badly in need of
> refactoring support so that would make a very interesting component to
> develop at Eclipse. I think lots of people would be interested in this,
> so opening a bugzilla in which to add attachments or links would allow
> many people to review it and comment on it. I look forward to seeing
> the details!
>
>
> Lars Schneider wrote:
>> If IBM employees can not access the update sites (located at Uni
>> Marburg and TU Berlin) I'll have to. But then I have to ask the people
>> from Berlin if it is okay to attach their sources, too, because of the
>> dependencies mentioned above.
>>
>> Tom Schindl wrote:
>>> Hi Lars,
>>>
>>> Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the
>>> sources there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to
>>> look into sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.
>>>
>>> Tom
>>>
>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>> Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted
>>>> you guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you
>>>> the update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is
>>>> updated because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they
>>>> will reply quickly.
>>>>
>>>> lars
>>>>
>>>> Timothy Marc wrote:
>>>>> Dear Lars,
>>>>>
>>>>> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>>>>>
>>>>> Thx
>>>>> Timothy
>>>>> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
>>>>> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>>>>>> Hi Lars,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Cheers
>>>>>> /Eike
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a
>>>>>>> first version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion
>>>>>>> but my email was not delivered.
>>>>>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first
>>>>>>> version he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update
>>>>>>> site here because it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Lars Schneider
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>
>>>
Reply 9. At 9:11 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Ed Merks wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin

Lars,

Here's a list of all the open bugs

https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/buglist.cgi?product=EMF&component=Core&component=Doc&component=Edit&component=Mapping&component=Tools&component=XML/XMI&bug_status=NEW&bug_status=ASSIGNED&bug_status=REOPENED&bug_status=RESOLVED&resolution=FIXED&resolution=---&order=bugs.bug_status,bugs.target_milestone,bugs.bug_id&query_format=advanced

Use this link, choose the "Edit" component, and mark the severity as "enhancement":

https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/enter_bug.cgi?product=EMF&component=Core%26component=Doc%26component=Edit%26component=Mapping%26component=Tools%26component=XML/XMI

You can add attachments too.

Lars Schneider wrote:
Ed,

yes, I wrote to merks @ ibm. I was going to open a bugzilla but wasn't sure how to fill out the forms. Is there an example you can give?

Lars

Ed Merks wrote:

Lars,

I suppose you emailed my IBM address and since I'm no longer at IBM, that won't work so well. My gmail email address will work better when using Ed.Merks in combination with it. We're certainly badly in need of refactoring support so that would make a very interesting component to develop at Eclipse. I think lots of people would be interested in this, so opening a bugzilla in which to add attachments or links would allow many people to review it and comment on it. I look forward to seeing the details!

Lars Schneider wrote:

If IBM employees can not access the update sites (located at Uni Marburg and TU Berlin) I'll have to. But then I have to ask the people from Berlin if it is okay to attach their sources, too, because of the dependencies mentioned above.

Tom Schindl wrote:

Hi Lars,

Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the sources there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to look into sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.

Tom

Lars Schneider schrieb:

Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted you guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you the update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is updated because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they will reply quickly.

lars

Timothy Marc wrote:

Dear Lars,

i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.

Thx
Timothy
"Eike Stepper" <stepper at sympedia dot de> schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org ...

Hi Lars,

This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.

Cheers
/Eike

Lars Schneider schrieb:

Hi,

I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a first version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion but my email was not delivered.
If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first version he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update site here because it is not ready to be published yet.

Lars Schneider
Reply 10. At 11:29 AM on Aug 7, 2008, Lars Schneider wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
I opened a bugzilla and hope that I filled out everthing correctly.
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=243432

Ed Merks wrote:
> Lars,
>
> I suppose you emailed my IBM address and since I'm no longer at IBM,
> that won't work so well. My gmail email address will work better when
> using Ed.Merks in combination with it. We're certainly badly in need of
> refactoring support so that would make a very interesting component to
> develop at Eclipse. I think lots of people would be interested in this,
> so opening a bugzilla in which to add attachments or links would allow
> many people to review it and comment on it. I look forward to seeing
> the details!
>
>
> Lars Schneider wrote:
>> If IBM employees can not access the update sites (located at Uni
>> Marburg and TU Berlin) I'll have to. But then I have to ask the people
>> from Berlin if it is okay to attach their sources, too, because of the
>> dependencies mentioned above.
>>
>> Tom Schindl wrote:
>>> Hi Lars,
>>>
>>> Might it not make more sense to file a bugzilla and attach the
>>> sources there. As far as I remember IBM employees are not allowed to
>>> look into sources out side eclipse-infrastructure because IP problems.
>>>
>>> Tom
>>>
>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>> Unfortunately there is not much to play with yet. Primarily I wanted
>>>> you guys to take a look at the design. Nevertheless I will send you
>>>> the update site link as soon as another plugin from TU Berlin is
>>>> updated because my plugin depends on some improvements. I hope they
>>>> will reply quickly.
>>>>
>>>> lars
>>>>
>>>> Timothy Marc wrote:
>>>>> Dear Lars,
>>>>>
>>>>> i'd like to participate the first-version-playing.
>>>>>
>>>>> Thx
>>>>> Timothy
>>>>> "Eike Stepper" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
>>>>> news:g7ebo8$ao0$1 at build dot eclipse dot org...
>>>>>> Hi Lars,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> This sounds very interesting! I'd really like to play with it.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Cheers
>>>>>> /Eike
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Lars Schneider schrieb:
>>>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> I am developing a refactoring for EMF. I already implemented a
>>>>>>> first version and now I wanted to ask Ed Merks for his oppinion
>>>>>>> but my email was not delivered.
>>>>>>> If someone else is interested in taking a look at this first
>>>>>>> version he or she can tell me but I don't want to post the update
>>>>>>> site here because it is not ready to be published yet.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Lars Schneider
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>
>>>
Reply 11. At 10:31 PM on Aug 12, 2008, Andrew H wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
FWIW Lack of refactoring is causing me a fair bit of pain. The main one
for me is moving ecore models & diagrams etc around. I have to edit the
xml which is a fiddly process.

So I'm very much looking forward this.
Reply 12. At 6:07 AM on Aug 13, 2008, Gitanjali Punj wrote:: xsd load and save
hi,
like for xmi import/export we have ecore's load and save api .what about
xsd schema?
Reply 13. At 6:43 AM on Aug 13, 2008, Ed Merks wrote:: Re: EMF Refactoring Plugin
Andrew,

This should be an easy problem to solve because all that needs to be
done is to load the resources, change their URIs and save them again...

I haven't gotten a chance to review the contribution yet.

Andrew H wrote:
> FWIW Lack of refactoring is causing me a fair bit of pain. The main
> one for me is moving ecore models & diagrams etc around. I have to
> edit the xml which is a fiddly process.
>
> So I'm very much looking forward this.
>
Reply 14. At 6:45 AM on Aug 13, 2008, Ed Merks wrote:: Re: xsd load and save
Gitanjali,

The org.eclipse.xsd plugin provides an XSDResourceImpl that's able to
load and save XSDs exactly the same as for Ecores.

Gitanjali Punj wrote:
> hi,
> like for xmi import/export we have ecore's load and save api .what
> about xsd schema?
>